Billecart-Salmon Elisabeth Salmon Rose 2012 Champagne / Magnum

Liam Anderson — Worth every penny for a special night

10/10

Bought the magnum for our 10th wedding anniversary and wow. The strawberry and rose thing on the nose is real — my wife noticed it before I even mentioned it. Bubbles are incredibly fine and creamy, and the finish just goes on and on. Yes it's £353 but for a magnum of something this good, I'd do it again.

Sara Lindstrom — The magnum makes a difference

9/10

I've had the regular bottle before and the magnum is noticeably better — smoother, more complex, the mousse is just silkier somehow. Wild strawberry and a kind of spiced dried flower thing on the nose. Served it at a dinner party and every single person commented on it. If you're going to splash out, go magnum.

Amira Benali — Very good but not life-changing

7/10

Look, it's a well-made rosé champagne and the strawberry and redcurrant flavours are genuinely lovely. The bubbles are fine and creamy and it drinks really smoothly. But I keep coming back to the price — £353 is a LOT of money and I think you're paying a premium for the name. I'd rather buy three bottles of something else and have a great weekend.