Paul Dethune Princesse des Thunes NV Champagne

James Okafor - Stood up to the whole meal

8/10

Opened this with starters and it was still great by dessert. Not one of those champagnes that gets lost after the first course — it's got enough going on to keep up with richer food. Complex without being try-hard, if that makes sense. At 12.5% it's easy drinking too, didn't feel heavy at all by the end of the night.

Finn OBrien - Birthday treat that delivered

9/10

My wife got me this for my 40th and wow, it's properly good champagne. Really layered smell — you keep finding new things every time you sniff it. Loads of depth on the taste too, not just fizzy wine like some cheaper stuff. At nearly £80 it's not an everyday thing but for a special occasion it's hard to beat.

Tyler Bennet - The wine shop guy was right

8/10

Went in looking for something for our anniversary and the guy behind the counter recommended this. Grand Cru apparently, which I'm told is a big deal. It's got a gorgeous nose on it and the acidity keeps everything fresh without being sharp. Felt like a proper treat and the finish just lingers nicely. Really glad I trusted his pick.

Nia Okafor - Nice but steep price

7/10

Had this at a friend's dinner party and it was lovely — clean finish, really well balanced, proper grown-up champagne. But then I looked up the price and £78 is a lot when there are great options at half that. Would I buy it myself? Probably not, but I'd happily drink someone else's bottle again.