Warre's Otima 10 Year Old

Daniel Oyama - Really nice port for the money

8/10

Picked this up from Majestic on a whim and honestly it's become my go-to after-dinner drink. Really aromatic when you pour it, and it's got this lovely warmth from the 10 years in cask without being heavy. At under £20 it's a proper bargain for tawny port.

Ethan Cooper - Great with a cheeseboard

7/10

Had this at a friend's house with stilton and crackers and immediately went and bought my own bottle. It's got a nice fruity flavour with enough acidity to stop it being cloying. Does exactly what you want a tawny port to do, nothing more nothing less.

Tomas Rivera - Solid everyday tawny

7/10

The wine shop guy recommended this when I said I wanted something for cheese nights. It's well balanced — fruity but not sweet, with a clean finish that keeps you going back for more. Not life-changing but genuinely enjoyable and the lower ABV means you don't feel wiped out after a couple of glasses.

Olivia Wong - Genuinely surprised by this

9/10

Saw this on a restaurant menu and ordered a glass on a whim. Went straight to the shop the next day. The complexity you get for £18-odd is mad — proper depth from the ageing, clean acidity, and a finish that just gently fades away. I've had 20 year tawnies that weren't this drinkable. Already on my second bottle.

Benjamin Ross - Birthday present win

8/10

My sister got me this for my birthday and I'm obsessed. It smells incredible straight out of the bottle and the finish just lingers in the best way. I'm not a massive port drinker normally but this is so easy to sip — the 14% ABV makes it way more approachable than most ports I've tried.

Kwame Mensah - Good but expected more

6/10

Bought this for a dinner party based on the Warre's name. It's decent — nice nose, pleasant enough to drink — but for nearly £19 I thought a 10 year old tawny would have a bit more depth to it. Would probably try something else next time at this price point.